Not logged inRybka Chess Community Forum
Up Topic The Rybka Lounge / Computer Chess / Stockfish_PV=10 crushes 61.5-38.5 KomodoMCTS13_PV=10 !!
- By MrKris (**) Date 2019-06-01 05:34
Matches at fixed time per move, as mentioned in my last post http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforum/topic_show.pl?tid=33048

All games 15" per move, Arena
all engines at PV=10 (Sf c=12, Ho & Ko c=0)
all at 6-cpu AMDphIIx6 512M hash Syzygy 6.

Stockfish PV=10 61.5-38.5 KomodoMCTS 13.01 PV=10
Openings HERT500 random50 (#1), colors reversed

Two miniatures won by Stockfish:
[Event "SfPV10-KoMPV10"]
[Site "Move/15'' 6cpu amdphII"]
[Date "2019.05.26"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Stockfish_19052509"]
[Black "KomodoMCTS-13.01L"]
[Result "1-0"]
[BlackElo "2200"]
[ECO "E26"]
[Opening "Nimzo-Indian"]
[Time "21:47:29"]
[Variation "Sämisch, 5...c5 6.e3 d6"]
[WhiteElo "2200"]
[TimeControl "0+15"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "48"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nc3 Bb4 4. a3 Bxc3+ 5. bxc3 c5 {-0.07/17 15} 6. e3
{+0.25/20 15} d6 {+0.04/18 14} 7. Bd3 {+0.35/21 15} Nc6 {+0.08/18 14} 8.
Ne2 {-0.07/21 15} b6 {+0.03/18 14} 9. O-O {-0.09/21 15} O-O {-0.14/17 14}
10. e4 {+0.30/22 15} h6 {-0.10/17 15} 11. f4 {+0.36/21 15} Ba6 {+0.27/18
14} 12. Rb1 {0.00/21 15} Na5 {+0.53/18 15} 13. e5 {-0.03/21 15} Nd7
{+0.25/18 14} 14. exd6 {-0.20/21 15} cxd4 {-0.01/18 14 ?} (14. .. Nf6 {! =
. Notes by Stockfish.}) 15. f5 {+0.83/21 15} dxc3 {0.00/18 14} (15. .. Bxc4
{!?}) 16. Nxc3 {+0.76/20 15} Bxc4 {-0.10/18 15} 17. Bxh6 {+1.21/21 15} Qf6
{+0.07/18 14 ??} (17. .. Qh4 18. Bf4 (18. Bxg7 {?} Kxg7) 18. .. Bxd3 19.
Qxd3 Qg4 20. Ne4 Qxf5 21. Rb5 {+/}) 18. Bxg7 {+4.07/21 15} Qxg7 {-4.16/18
14} (18. .. Kxg7 {?} 19. Qg4+ Kh8 20. fxe6) 19. Bxc4 {+4.40/22 15} Ne5
{-3.97/19 15} (19. .. Nxc4 20. Rf3) 20. Ba2 {+7.23/21 15} Qg5 {-6.33/18 15}
21. Rb4 {+8.48/21 15} Qe3+ {-5.59/18 14} 22. Kh1 {+11.34/26 14} Qg5
{-8.06/19 14} 23. Rbf4 {+11.53/21 15} Qh6 {-10.00/18 14} 24. Qe1 {+13.05/20
15} Nac6 {-12.58/18 14  Black resigns} 1-0

[Event "SfPV10-KoMPV10"]
[Site "Move/15'' 6cpu amdphII"]
[Date "2019.05.27"]
[Round "31"]
[White "Stockfish_19052509"]
[Black "KomodoMCTS-13.01L"]
[Result "1-0"]
[BlackElo "2200"]
[ECO "B26"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Time "11:58:17"]
[Variation "Closed, 6.Be3 Nf6 7.h3"]
[WhiteElo "2200"]
[TimeControl "0+15"]
[Termination "normal"]
[PlyCount "52"]
[WhiteType "program"]
[BlackType "program"]

1. e4 c5 2. Nc3 Nc6 3. g3 g6 4. Bg2 Bg7 5. d3 d6 6. Be3 Nf6 {+0.07/18 14}
7. h3 {+0.33/19 15} Bd7 {+0.03/18 14} 8. Nge2 {+0.43/19 15} O-O {0.00/18
14} 9. O-O {+0.56/20 15} Rb8 {+0.02/18 14} 10. a3 {+0.61/20 15} e5
{+0.01/18 15} 11. f4 {+0.72/20 15} Nd4 {+0.07/18 14} 12. f5 {+0.79/20 15}
Bc6 {-0.33/18 14} 13. g4 {+1.18/20 15} gxf5 {-0.31/18 14} 14. exf5
{+1.97/22 15} h6 {-0.67/18 14} 15. g5 {+1.42/20 15} hxg5 {-0.41/18 15} 16.
Bxg5 {+1.23/21 15} d5 {-0.22/18 14} 17. Nxd4 {+0.96/20 15} cxd4 {-0.25/18
15} 18. Ne2 {+0.98/20 15} Qd6 {-0.10/18 14} 19. Qe1 {+1.35/20 15} Ba4
{-0.32/18 15 ??} (19. .. Nh7 20. f6 Nxf6) 20. Qh4 {+2.42/20 15} Rfc8
{-1.02/18 14} 21. Rf3 {+3.02/21 15} Nh7 {-1.25/18 15} (21. .. Kf8) 22. f6
{+7.07/23 15} Rxc2 {-2.92/18 14} 23. Rg3 {+8.02/22 15} Kh8 {-5.60/18 15}
24. fxg7+ {+13.64/23 15} Kg8 {-11.74/18 14} 25. Rf1 {+14.09/21 15} Rc7
{-8.99/19 14} 26. Rf6 {+16.49/20 15} Qxf6 {-12.20/18 15  Black resigns} 1-0


KomodoMCTS 13.01 PV=10 59.0-41.0 Houdini 6.03 PV=10
Same as above openings HERT500 random50 (#1), colors reversed

A nice win over Houdini:
[Event "KoMPV10-HoPV10"]
[Site "All Engines at PV=10"]
[Date "2019.05.27"]
[Round "21"]
[White "Houdini-6.03std"]
[Black "KomodoMCTS-13.01"]
[Result "0-1"]
[BlackElo "2200"]
[ECO "B39"]
[Opening "Sicilian"]
[Time "03:53:36"]
[Variation "Maroczy Bind, Breyer, 8.Qxg4 Nxd4 9.Qd1 Ne6 10.Rc1"]
[WhiteElo "2200"]
[TimeControl "0+15"]
[Termination "adjudication"]
[PlyCount "100"]
[WhiteType "human"]
[BlackType "human"]

1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 g6 5. c4 Bg7 6. Be3 Nf6 7. Nc3 Ng4
8. Qxg4 {+0.31/18 15} Nxd4 {-0.40/18 15} 9. Qd1 {+0.45/17 15} Ne6 {-0.52/18
15} 10. Rc1 {+0.51/17 15} b6 {-0.55/18 15} 11. g3 {+0.63/17 15} h5
{-0.47/18 15} 12. Qd2 {+0.86/16 16} Bb7 {-0.41/18 15} 13. Bg2 {+0.50/17 15}
h4 {-0.37/18 15} 14. Nd5 {+0.59/17 15} d6 {-0.37/18 15} 15. O-O {+0.70/16
16} hxg3 {-0.47/18 15} 16. fxg3 {+0.82/16 16} Be5 {-0.20/18 15} 17. Qf2
{+0.60/16 15} f6 {-0.13/18 15} 18. b4 {+0.67/16 15} Kf7 {0.00/17 15} 19. h4
{+0.42/16 15} Rc8 {+0.01/18 15} 20. Bf3 {+0.36/17 15} Bc6 {+0.05/18 15} 21.
Rfd1 {+0.33/17 15} Qg8 {+0.09/18 15} 22. Bg4 {+0.28/16 16} Bd7 {+0.06/18
15} 23. Rd3 {0.00/17 15} Qd8 {+0.01/18 15} 24. Bh3 {0.00/17 15} g5
{+0.47/18 15} 25. Ra3 {0.00/16 15} gxh4 {+0.20/18 15} 26. Rxa7 {0.00/17 15}
Ra8 {+0.48/18 15} 27. Rxd7 {-0.43/16 15} Qxd7 {+0.28/18 15} 28. Qf5
{-0.81/16 16} Nf8 {+0.56/18 15} 29. Qxd7 {-0.37/16 15} Nxd7 {+0.72/18 15}
30. Bxd7 {-0.48/17 15} Ra7 {+0.78/18 15} 31. Bc6 {-0.12/17 16} Rxa2
{+1.55/18 15} 32. Nf4 {-0.05/16 15} e6 {+2.34/18 15} 33. Bd7 {-1.15/17 15}
Bxf4 {+3.03/18 15} 34. Bxf4 {-1.77/18 16} e5 {+3.22/18 15} 35. Be3
{-1.84/17 15} hxg3 {+3.77/18 15} 36. Rf1 {-2.04/19 15} Rhh2 {+4.17/18 15}
37. Re1 {-2.01/20 15} Rh4 {+4.55/18 15} 38. Rf1 {-2.02/19 16} Ke7 {+3.91/18
15} 39. Bf5 {-1.33/18 15} Rhh2 {+4.50/18 15} 40. Re1 {-2.59/21 15} Rag2+
{+5.09/18 15} 41. Kf1 {-3.73/28 15} Rb2 {+4.96/18 15} 42. Kg1 {-3.89/26 17}
Rxb4 {+5.35/18 15} 43. Rd1 {-3.37/21 15} Re2 {+6.54/18 15} 44. Bd2
{-4.27/19 15} Rxc4 {+7.19/18 15} 45. Be1 {-4.50/19 15} Rec2 {+6.83/18 15}
46. Rd3 {-5.89/21 16} Rc1 {+5.83/18 15} 47. Rxg3 {-6.05/20 15} Rxe1+
{+6.26/17 15} 48. Kf2 {-8.23/25 15} Rec1 {+8.76/18 15} 49. Rg7+ {-8.77/22
15} Kf8 {+7.75/17 15} 50. Rb7 {-8.84/22 15} Rc6 {+7.51/18 15  Arena
Adjudication} 0-1


'Bonus' RR: Move/15", 36 games, same cpu etc. as above,
3 openings reversed, all engines PV=10:
1. Stockfish 12.0/18
2. Ko.MCTS 13.01 11.0/18
3.Houdini 6std 10.0/18
4.Komodo 13.01 3.0/18
showing Komodo 13.01 regular is extrodinarily weak at multi-PV.


Attachment: SfPV10-KoMPV10.pgn - games (275k)
Attachment: KoMPV10-HoPV10.pgn - games (264k)
Attachment: PV10--KoMSfHoKo.pgn - games (89k)
-

All: PV=10 Move/15" 6cpu, AMDphIIx6 Sy.6 512M Arena

HERT500_random1-50 colors reversed, 100 games total:

1: Stockfish_19052509_PV=10 61.5/100 .................................................................................................... 
2: KomodoMCTS-13.01L_PV=10  38.5/100 0=====0===0=010=0==10==00=====0===1=====100=0==000010=0=00==011=0100=1==0====1=00======0==0=0====00= 
                               Elo    +   -  Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws
1 Stockfish_19052509_PV=10  :   82   45  44   100    61.5 %      0   57.0 %
2 KomodoMCTS-13.01L_PV=10   :    0   44  45   100    38.5 %     82   57.0 %
______________________________


HERT500_random1-50 colors reversed, 100 games total:
                                                                                     
1: KomodoMCTS-13.01_PV=10 59.0/100 ==11=1=====1=====1==1=1=======00=1======1==1===0==1===0111===110===1===101100===1=1==1=1===1=====1== 
2: Houdini-6.03std_PV=10  41.0/100 ···································································································· 

wh+20 =66 bk+14, wh. 53%, draws 66%
___________________________________

RR, 36 games total:
                             Score    St     Ko     Ho     Ko      S-B
1: Stockfish_19052509_PV=10 12.0/18 ······ 1=011= =10=== 1=11=1   89.00
2: KomodoMCTS-13.01_PV=10   11.0/18 0=100= ······ 1=1=== 1111==   79.00
3: Houdini-6.03std_PV=10    10.0/18 =01=== 0=0=== ······ 1111==   73.00
4: Komodo-13.01_PV=10        3.0/18 0=00=0 0000== 0000== ······   33.00

All, colors reversed: 
wh+5 =4 bk+3  a) 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 d6 3.d4 cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6
wh+5 =2 bk+5  b) 1.e4 d5 2.exd5 Qxd5  
wh+2 =10 bk+0 c) 1.d4 d5 2.c4 dxc4 3.e4 
overall wh+12 =16 bk+8, wh. 56%, draws 44%
Up Topic The Rybka Lounge / Computer Chess / Stockfish_PV=10 crushes 61.5-38.5 KomodoMCTS13_PV=10 !!

Powered by mwForum 2.27.4 © 1999-2012 Markus Wichitill